First set the scope of the job, then compare the price

A freight forwarder for importing from China organises the agreed activities related to carriage. The scope of customs handling, insurance or contact with the factory must, however, be confirmed in the offer. The label "door-to-door transport" alone does not tell you whether the price includes collection in China, clearance, delivery to the warehouse and return of the empty container. Ask for these stages to be stated in writing.

Compare offers for the same cargo, date and point where the service ends. In one proposal the final price may be delivery to the warehouse, in another only the container's arrival at the port. Setting freight amounts alone side by side will not show this difference. We also write about the relationship between an offer price and a market indicator in the guide what a container really costs: offer versus index.

A good answer from a forwarder lets you reconstruct the calculation. You know which costs are confirmed, what assumptions were made and what can trigger a surcharge. A missing explanation does not prove that the company is unreliable, but it does mean the offer needs clarifying before you compare it with competitors.

Freight forwarder comparing routes and transport terms from ChinaAI image
Freight forwarder comparing routes and transport terms from China

Send every forwarder the same set of data

Prepare one description of the enquiry and use it for all quotes. State the place of collection and delivery, the Incoterms with the named place, the cargo ready date, a description of the product and the required delivery date. Add the number of packages, their dimensions, gross weight and whether they can be stacked. Indicate any special requirements arising from the properties of the cargo. You can dictate such a description faster than you can type it: a free dictation program will type it straight into the email window, and you only check the figures.

Do not mark the factory ready date as certain if you have no confirmation. Ask what will happen to the booking and the price if production is delayed. For delivery to a warehouse, describe access restrictions, availability of a loading dock, the method of unloading and the booking rules. This information helps you avoid a situation where only the driver discovers that a different vehicle is needed.

Also ask for the assumptions that need confirming to be indicated. If the forwarder has assumed standard goods without transport restrictions, and you are ordering a product with a battery, correct this before choosing the offer. Changing the cargo description after booking may mean a new quote is needed.

Table of freight forwarding offer components

You can copy the table below into your enquiry. For each item ask for the amount, currency, charging unit and a marking: included, separate or out of scope. An empty field does not mean zero cost. If a given service is not needed, ask for confirmation of the reason.

Table of freight forwarding offer components
ComponentWhat should be describedQuestion for the forwarder
Collection and handling in ChinaAddress, loading, transport to the terminal, local documentsWhich costs does the factory cover under the agreed terms?
Main freightPorts or terminals, type of cargo, route and transhipmentsDoes the rate apply to a confirmed date and available space?
Freight surchargesNames of surcharges, rules for change, date of validityWhich surcharges are included, and which may be added after booking?
Handling at the destination portTranshipment, documents, cargo release, local agentWill I get the full list of local charges before placing the order?
Clearance and representationAgency, scope of activities, documents and powers of attorneyDoes the quote include clearance handling, with duties and taxes shown separately?
Cargo insuranceScope of cover, exclusions, excess, sum insuredWill I receive the terms and confirmation of cover for this shipment?
Delivery to the warehouseAddress, type of vehicle, booking, waiting time and unloadingWho organises unloading and how much time is included in the price?
Container returnPlace of return, transport and deadlineDoes delivery include returning the empty container to the specified depot?
Exceeding free timeDemurrage, detention and storage termsFrom when does each period run and under what tariff are charges calculated?
SettlementCurrencies, exchange rate, invoice date, offer validityWhich rate, and from which day, will you apply to each item?

Check demurrage, detention and storage separately in the terms of the relevant carrier, terminal and offer. Ask for a description of the event that starts the charging and the calendar of free days. Also ask whether the free time offered is combined or split. A promise of "a few days without charges" alone does not let you plan a safe collection.

How to use freight indices when choosing an offer

Drewry WCI is a composite index based on various routes. It is not a ready price list for a specific shipment from China to your warehouse. The rates included in the index have a defined scope of sea costs and surcharges, and inland transport is excluded. Details are given in the Drewry WCI methodology.

How to use freight indices when choosing an offer
IndicatorValueReading dateHow to use it in the conversation
Drewry WCI, composite index4,500 USD per 40-foot container2026-09-17Background on market change, keeping in mind the differences between routes and scope of services

The reading is recorded in ImportPanel data and confirmed in the Drewry WCI publication of 17 September 2026. It is a reference point for the stated day, not a transport offer or a promise of a rate. Check current data before a new order; an overview of the indicators is in our article on the cost of freight from China.

If an offer differs significantly from another proposal, first check the scope and route. Only then ask about market change, the sailing date or booking terms. A price below the global WCI is not in itself a sign of an error. It may concern a completely different leg, period or set of charges. Nor should you compare index points with an invoice amount as if they had the same unit.

Hypothetical example: lower freight, higher total cost

The amounts below are purely a calculation example. They do not come from a completed job or from current offers and do not constitute a market price list. We assume the same scope of delivery to the warehouse, one settlement currency and no additional delays. Duty, VAT and the value of the goods remain outside the comparison of transport services.

Hypothetical example: lower freight, higher total cost
Example componentOffer A, USDOffer B, USD
Main freight3,0003,250
Other agreed transport and handling charges950650
Cargo insurance on comparable terms100100
Total price for the compared scope4,0504,000

Offer A has main freight lower by 250 USD, but after adding the other items it is dearer by 50 USD. This is the result of working with invented amounts, showing the method of comparison. In a real enquiry, split the combined charges item according to the earlier table and check the documents confirming the scope of both offers.

Next, compare a scenario of delayed collection. Do not add one random reserve: ask for the specific tariff and charging terms. A cheaper base offer may become dearer after waiting time, but it may also remain favourable. The result is decided by terms that can be checked before signing the order.

Clearance, documents and liability

Establish who is the forwarder, who is the carrier and who is the customs representative. Check the company details and ask for documents concerning the declared liability insurance. Do not treat the forwarder's policy as an automatic equivalent of cargo insurance for your goods. Ask for a description of the claims procedure, the evidence required and a contact person.

For clearance, agree who prepares the classification of the goods and who approves the data before the declaration. Provide the specification instead of basing arrangements on a shortened name from the invoice. The guide how to check a CN code is helpful. The assessment of duties should refer to the specific product, origin and relevant tariff measures, not to a general slogan of "standard duty".

The option to settle import VAT has to be agreed with your accountants and the party handling clearance for your situation; the procedure is discussed in the article on Article 33a of the VAT Act. Separately, agree the scope of checking product requirements. A transport service does not confirm that a product complies with regulations. Nor should you assume that every importer needs a separate EU representative: for products covered by the GPSR, the relevant roles and obligations are set out in Regulation (EU) 2023/988.

Checklist of questions before signing the order

  • To exactly what place does the price cover me, and which stages remain with the factory or the importer?
  • How long is the offer valid, and does the booking confirm the rate and space on a specific means of transport?
  • What will change in the price if the factory delays the cargo ready date or the carrier changes the schedule?
  • Which surcharges are variable, who charges them and what document will be the basis for the charge?
  • How are free days counted, and the charges for exceeding time in and outside the port?
  • Who monitors documents and informs me of gaps before the cargo arrives?
  • Who handles clearance, and how will we approve the data passed for the declaration?
  • What cargo cover terms will I receive, and how do I report damage or a shortage in part of the cargo?
  • What settlement rate will be applied, and when must the individual invoices be paid?
  • Who handles the case operationally, and to whom do I escalate a problem when the account manager is unavailable?

Ask about experience on a similar route and with similar goods. A list of well-known clients alone does not explain how the company will handle your warehouse constraints or documentation requirements. It is worth asking for a description of how they act when a sailing is cancelled, a document is missing or a claim is made. Judge how specific the answers are and whether the arrangements make it into the order.

Brief conclusions for choosing a forwarder

First, reject comparisons of incomplete scopes. Then calculate the whole service in a consistent currency, check the surcharge terms and assess how contact is organised. Choose the offer whose cost and limitations you can explain to the person approving the purchase. Keep the accepted quote with its attachments, because you will return to it when checking the invoice.

After the first delivery, compare the settlement with the arrangements: which surcharges actually arose, what caused them and when you were informed of them. Such a summary gives a better basis for the next choice than the mere memory that the container arrived on time.

Frequently asked questions

Is the cheapest forwarder always the riskiest?

No. First level out the scope of services, dates and surcharge terms. A lower price may be justified, but it must concern the same task. The absence of a quote for one stage does not mean it will be free of charge.

Is an offer below the WCI suspicious?

This cannot be judged from the comparison alone. WCI is a composite index, while an offer concerns a specific route and scope. Check comparability before drawing a conclusion about the quality of the service.

Does the forwarder's policy replace cargo insurance?

Do not assume these forms of protection are equivalent. Ask what events the proposed cover for your cargo includes, what the exclusions are and who is entitled to report a claim. Ask for the terms before shipment.

What should I do if the offer does not include local port charges?

Ask for a quote for them or an unambiguous statement of the exclusion. Until you get an answer, treat the offer as incomplete. Do not enter zero in the cost comparison just because the cell in the table is empty.

Is it worth asking for an alternative rail option?

Yes, if you want to compare options for a specific delivery date. Ask for the full route, the expected schedule, the scope of charges and the terms of performance. The slogan "faster than by sea" alone does not replace a comparable offer.