The short answer: the index measures a different basket of routes

A forwarder's offer for a container from China to Poland is often clearly lower than the Drewry WCI index, because the figure quoted in headlines (WCI composite) is not the price of the route to Europe. It is an average of eight routes, in which shipments from Shanghai to Los Angeles and New York also carry weight, and these are today more than twice as expensive as carriage to Rotterdam. For Europe, Drewry publishes a separate Shanghai-Rotterdam rate, and only that is worth setting against offers from China to Gdansk.

The figures from 24 September 2026 show the scale of this difference well. WCI composite stood at 4,468 USD then (40-foot container), the Shanghai-Rotterdam route at 3,485 USD and the Shanghai-Los Angeles route at 7,838 USD. On our board in the same week the lowest freight alone from Ningbo to Gdansk for a 40HC container was 2,600 USD, and the lowest complete offer to port, that is freight together with THC, clearance and documents, 3,210 USD. The difference between 4,468 and 2,600 looks like a chasm, but once broken down into parts it is almost entirely explained and there is nothing suspicious about it.

An analyst compares two sheets with freight quotes by a window overlooking the portAI image
An analyst compares two sheets with freight quotes by a window overlooking the port

What WCI composite really measures

The Drewry World Container Index is a weekly assessment of spot rates for carrying a 40-foot container on eight main routes between Asia, Europe and North America. The composite result is the average of these routes. It includes lanes on which a great deal is paid today, such as shipments from Shanghai to US ports, but also return lanes and transatlantic routes where rates look completely different. A Polish importer in practice uses one of these markets, the Asia-North Europe route. The composite therefore tells them about the general mood in container shipping, but not about the price of their container.

The second reason for the divergence is the different pace of change on individual routes. In the week ending 24 September Drewry recorded a fall in the Shanghai-Rotterdam rate of 4 per cent and Shanghai-Genoa of 5 per cent, while at the same time the Shanghai-Los Angeles rate rose by 2 per cent. The composite fell by only 1 per cent. Anyone looking only at this single figure sees a market standing almost still, while on the route to Europe prices are clearly coming down.

The WCI readings recorded in our database show the same picture over a longer period. WCI composite has held in a narrow band since August: 4,526 USD (reading 2026-08-20), 4,473 USD (reading 2026-08-27), 4,500 USD (reading 2026-09-17). During this time the first offer on our board, of 17 August, had freight of 3,570 USD for a 40HC container from Ningbo, and offers of 22 September started from 2,600 USD. The index stood still, while offers to Poland became cheaper by roughly a quarter. For comparison: in 2026 WCI composite ranged from 1,899 USD (reading 2026-02-26) to 4,639 USD (reading 2026-07-09), so the scale of movements in the index itself is also large; its direction simply need not match the direction on the route to Poland.

Shanghai-Rotterdam: the right reference point for Poland

The Shanghai-Rotterdam rate is the closest public equivalent of what a Polish importer pays for sea freight from China. Rotterdam is the main port of Northern Europe, and ships from Asia to Gdansk sail the same corridor, often calling at North Sea ports along the way. Some services reach Gdansk directly, because its deep-water terminal handles the largest container ships. Other containers reach Poland on a smaller feeder vessel after transhipment in one of the western ports. In both cases the freight price is formed on the Asia-North Europe market, not the transpacific one.

Even this route is not the price on your invoice, however. The index describes carriage from Shanghai, while most offers on our board concern Ningbo, the neighbouring port on the other side of Hangzhou Bay. Drewry assesses spot rates collected from many market participants, while a forwarder builds its offer from its contracts with shipping lines, volume discounts and its own margin. If it has a contract signed when the market was cheaper, or if it wants to fill its space allocation on a ship before the end of the month, its offer can drop below the index even for the same route. It works the other way too: at peak season, with space short, an offer can be higher than the index.

This gives a simple order of comparison. First set the offer against the Shanghai-Rotterdam rate from the same week, to check whether it is within a reasonable range of the market to Europe. Then compare it with other offers for the same route and the same container type, because these are your real alternative. Leave the composite for assessing the general trend, preferably on a chart covering several months.

Five reasons why an offer drops below the index

The difference between the index and an offer rarely has a single cause. Usually several factors overlap at once, and together they produce the several hundred or more than a thousand dollars you see in a comparison with the composite:

  • A different basket of routes. The composite contains routes to the US that are more than twice as expensive as carriage to Europe, so this fact alone lifts it well above offers to Poland.
  • A different port of loading. Offers most often concern Ningbo, not Shanghai, which means a different service, sometimes a different shipping line and a different pattern of space allocations.
  • A different type of rate. The forwarder sells from a contract or from an allocation bought earlier, while the index measures the current spot market.
  • Index lag. A weekly assessment shows the position of a few days earlier, so in a falling market offers come down faster than the index.
  • A different scope of items. The "freight" line alone in an offer does not always include all the surcharges contained in the index rate.

The last point matters most when judging whether a cheap offer is really cheap. The bunker surcharge (BAF), the surcharge for the EU Emissions Trading System, the fee for the safety and security declaration before arrival in the EU or a seasonal surcharge may be included in the freight or listed separately in small print below the table. With two offers differing by a hundred or two hundred dollars, it is usually precisely these items that decide which is cheaper. Before you treat an offer as a bargain, ask directly whether the rate is "all in" to the destination port and what charges may still be added.

When an offer below the index should ring alarm bells

An offer lower than the composite is no cause for concern, because, as shown above, that is the normal state of the market this year. Alarm bells should ring only when an offer is clearly lower than other offers for the same route, the same container and the same week. If freight from Ningbo to Gdansk on the board falls within a range of 2,600 to 3,300 USD, and you receive a proposal several hundred dollars below the lower limit, it is worth asking for details before you book space.

Typical explanations for such a difference are innocent, but you need to know them: a short offer validity, a "subject to space availability" proviso, a service with transhipment and a longer transit time, or a different container type, for example a 20-foot one instead of a 40HC. It also happens that an offer lacks an item that a competitor includes. On our board on 22 September one offer showed a total to port of 3,110 USD, apparently less than the 3,210 USD in the offer considered the cheapest. The difference arose because the first did not include customs clearance or documents. That is why the board calculates the minimum and median only from offers that have the full set of items to port.

Table: index, route and board in the same week

Below is a summary of the figures referred to in the text. WCI readings come from Drewry quotations that we record in our database, and offers from the ImportPanel board. Amounts per 40-foot container (40HC in offers), in US dollars.

Table: index, route and board in the same week
ItemAmount (USD)Reading dateSource
WCI composite, average of eight routes4,500reading 2026-09-17Drewry World Container Index
WCI composite, average of eight routes4,468reading 2026-09-24Drewry World Container Index
Shanghai-Rotterdam3,485reading 2026-09-24Drewry World Container Index
Shanghai-Genoa3,835reading 2026-09-24Drewry World Container Index
Shanghai-Los Angeles7,838reading 2026-09-24Drewry World Container Index
Lowest 40HC freight Ningbo-Gdansk2,600reading 2026-09-22ImportPanel board
Lowest complete offer to port 40HC Ningbo-Gdansk3,210reading 2026-09-22ImportPanel board

The most important pair in this table is 3,485 and 3,210. The first figure is the market spot rate for carriage from Shanghai to Rotterdam, the second is the real, cheapest complete offer from Ningbo to Gdansk including charges at the destination port. They lie close to each other, and the difference is consistent with the fact that the market to Europe was falling in these weeks, while offers on the board react faster than a weekly assessment. Comparing 4,468 with 2,600, by contrast, sets a world average against the freight line alone on one route, and that is why it misleads.

How to use this with your own quote

With every new quote from a forwarder, start by checking what the rate on the route to Europe looks like in the same week. We keep the full history of WCI and the other indices on the freight rates from China page, and the methodological differences between WCI, SCFI and ERAI are described in our guide to freight indices. The index will tell you whether the market is rising or falling, and whether your forwarder is keeping up with that movement.

The second step is comparison with offers for the same route. On the forwarder offers board you can see current offers broken down into freight, THC, clearance, documents and delivery, and in the Your rate versus the board section you enter your total to port and immediately see how it compares with the minimum and median on the board. The amounts are calculated in your browser and we do not save them anywhere.

The third step is deciding whether and when to negotiate. If your offer is above the board median and the index on the European route is falling, you have a strong argument for the conversation. If it is below the median and the index is rising, it is better to confirm the booking quickly. Read more about choosing the moment in the article on when it is worth negotiating a freight rate, and about the difference between the index and the price on the invoice in the article what a container from China really costs.

Checklist: how to set an offer against the index

  • Check whether the figure from the headlines is WCI composite, that is the average of eight world routes, and not the price of the route to Europe.
  • Set the offer against the Shanghai-Rotterdam rate from the same week, not against the composite.
  • Make sure you are comparing the same container type and a similar port of loading.
  • Ask the forwarder whether the freight is "all in" and which surcharges may be added separately.
  • Compare the offer with other offers for the same route and the same week on the board.
  • With an offer clearly lower than others, ask about validity, provisos and transhipment.

Frequently asked questions

Is WCI useless for an importer from Poland?

No. The composite shows the general direction in container shipping well, and the Shanghai-Rotterdam rate, published by Drewry in the same assessment, is a good reference point for freight to Europe. The only mistake is comparing the composite with a single offer to Gdansk.

Why not compare the offer with SCFI?

SCFI is also an index composed of many routes out of Shanghai, and it gives the result in points, not in dollars per container. It is suitable for following the trend, but not for direct comparison with the amount in an offer.

Is an offer far below the index an attempt at fraud?

Usually not. Most often it results from a different basket of routes in the index, a different port of loading or the fact that some surcharges are listed separately. Compare it with other offers for the same route and ask for confirmation that the rate covers all charges to the destination port.

How often does the difference between the index and offers change?

Every week. The index is published on Thursdays, and offers on the board are usually valid for about two weeks. In a falling market offers come down faster than the index; in a rising one it is sometimes the other way round.

Sources

  • Drewry World Container Index, assessment of 24 September 2026: Drewry index page
  • WCI readings in the ImportPanel database (series since 2016), readings of 17 and 24 September 2026
  • ImportPanel forwarder offers board, offers approved manually, state of the board on 27 September 2026