How to compare freight forwarder quotes fairly
Freight forwarder quotes for a container from China are compared fairly when each one answers the same enquiry, is broken down into the same items (freight, surcharges, THC, clearance, documents, delivery) and has its gaps filled in. Only after such standardisation does the final total tell the truth. Comparing only the amounts "at the bottom of the quote" regularly leads to choosing a quote that only looks cheaper.
We see this every day on our board. Freight forwarders send quotes in different layouts: one includes documents in clearance, a second leaves out clearance because it assumes the client's agency will do it, a third gives freight with surcharges, and a fourth lists surcharges separately under the table. Each of these quotes can be reliable, but none can be compared with another without preparation. Below is a four-step method and an example with real figures.

Collect quotes on the same terms
The comparison starts before you receive the quotes, with the enquiry. Send all freight forwarders an identical set of data: port of loading or factory address, destination port and delivery address in Poland, type and number of containers, approximate weight and volume, type of goods with the CN code, the date the goods will be ready and the delivery terms agreed with the supplier, for example FOB or EXW. Under FOB the supplier is responsible for delivering the goods to the port and for export clearance in China; under EXW these tasks fall on you and your freight forwarder, so the quotes will look different.
If one freight forwarder is told the goods will be ready in a week and another in a month, their quotes may relate to different vessels and a different state of the market. If one quotes delivery to Gdansk and another to the door of your warehouse, the final totals will not be comparable. The simplest way to avoid these traps is one enquiry template, sent on the same day to everyone. We wrote more about how to choose a freight forwarder and what to ask in the article how to choose a freight forwarder for importing from China.
Break each quote down into the same columns
The second step is copying each quote into one table with fixed columns. On the board we use the layout: freight, THC, clearance, documents, delivery, and from these we calculate the total to port and the total to door. When comparing your own quotes, it is worth adding one more column for surcharges listed separately.
Freight is the shipping line's rate for carrying the container from port to port. It may or may not include the bunker adjustment factor (BAF) and other surcharges, so always check whether "all in" appears next to the freight. Typical surcharges listed separately include: BAF, the surcharge connected with the EU Emissions Trading System (shipping lines have added it to voyages to EU ports since 2024), the fee for the ENS safety and security declaration in the ICS2 system, and a peak season surcharge. THC is the charge for handling the container at the terminal, in import quotes usually at the destination port. Clearance is the import customs declaration, and documents are the charges for the bill of lading, container release and similar activities. Delivery is truck transport from the port to the warehouse. We described the meaning of the individual items and how they vary in more detail in the article what makes up the price of a container.
Fill in the gaps and standardise the currency
The third step is the one most often skipped. If a quote is missing an item, do not assume it is free. Ask the freight forwarder whether the activity is included in another item or simply falls outside the scope of the quote. In the latter case, add the cost you will actually incur, for example the customs agency's fee for clearance. Until you get an answer, you can use typical amounts from the board: clearance there usually costs from 65 to 85 USD, and documents from 35 to 65 USD.
The second issue is currency. Freight is almost always in dollars, but clearance, delivery or documents are sometimes in zloty or euro. Convert everything into one currency, at one rate from one day. At the NBP mid rate of 3.8404 PLN per dollar from 25 September 2026, clearance for 300 zloty is about 78 USD, and delivery for 4,500 zloty is about 1,172 USD. A difference of one grosz in the rate changes such a delivery by about 3 USD, so for these items the rate matters little.
Freight itself weighs much more. The scale of its fluctuations is shown by the Drewry WCI index: this year's lowest reading was 1,899 USD (reading of 26 February 2026), and the highest 4,639 USD (reading of 9 July 2026), more than twice as much. With freight paid in dollars in a few weeks' time, what matters more than the rate on the day of the quote is the rate at which you actually buy the currency, but that is a separate decision, independent of the choice of freight forwarder.
Table: three real quotes from one day
Below are three quotes for a 40HC container from Ningbo that reached our board on 22 September 2026. We omit the names of the freight forwarders and label the quotes with letters. This is what the items looked like in each of them:
- Quote A: freight 2,650 USD, THC 430 USD, clearance 80 USD, documents 50 USD, delivery to warehouse 1,180 USD.
- Quote B: freight 2,600 USD, THC 420 USD, clearance 85 USD, no documents, delivery 1,200 USD.
- Quote C: freight 2,650 USD, THC 460 USD, no clearance, no documents and no delivery.
| Quote | Amount to port according to the quote (USD) | What the quote is missing | Amount after filling the gaps (USD) | Reading date | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quote A | 3,210 | nothing, complete set of items | 3,210 | reading 2026-09-22 | ImportPanel board |
| Quote B | 3,105 | documents | about 3,170 | reading 2026-09-22 | ImportPanel board |
| Quote C | 3,110 | clearance and documents | about 3,240 | reading 2026-09-22 | ImportPanel board |
| Background: Drewry WCI, highest reading of 2026 (average of eight world routes) | 4,639 | not applicable | not applicable | reading 2026-07-09 | Drewry World Container Index |
At first glance, quote B is the cheapest to port, with quote C close behind, both clearly below quote A. After filling in the gaps, the picture changes. Quote C is missing clearance and documents. After adding the typical amounts from the board (80 and 50 USD), its total to port rises to about 3,240 USD, above quote A. Quote B is missing only documents. Even after adding the upper typical amount (65 USD), it comes to about 3,170 USD, so it remains the cheapest, although its advantage over quote A shrinks from over a hundred to a few dozen dollars.
The conclusion is simple: the order of the quotes after filling in the gaps was different from the order by the totals given by the freight forwarders. That is why the board calculates the minimum and median to port only from quotes that have a complete set of items, and shows incomplete quotes but does not include them in comparisons. In this example the cheapest complete quote was A, and B could overtake it only after confirming how much the documents cost.
What you cannot see in the total
The fourth step is the terms that have no column in the table but can change the cost more than a hundred-dollar difference in freight. The most important of them:
- Quote validity and reservations. A quote valid for three days or with a note about space availability is different from a quote valid for two weeks with confirmed space.
- Free time from storage and detention charges. The number of days a container can stand in the port and at your premises without additional charges differs between shipping lines and quotes. A delayed clearance with short free time quickly costs more than the whole difference in freight.
- Transit time and transhipments. A cheaper quote may relate to a service with transhipment and a longer voyage.
- Scope of liability and insurance. Check whether the cargo is insured and up to what amount, because the carrier's standard liability is limited.
- Payment terms. Prepayment before sailing and payment after arrival mean different financing costs.
These terms are worth writing down in additional rows of the same table. Then the decision is based not on one figure but on the full picture of the quote.
Compare with the market, not just among themselves
Even the most carefully standardised three quotes only tell you which of them is the cheapest. They do not tell you whether all three are expensive. That is why the last step is a comparison with the market. On the forwarder offers board you can see current quotes for the same route, already broken down into items, and in the Your rate versus the board section you can enter the total to port of your best quote and see how it compares with the minimum and median. We show the general direction of the market and the freight indices on the freight rates from China page.
Comparing transport costs is only part of the calculation. Before you decide on an order, check whether the goods are subject to anti-dumping duty, because with such measures the customs cost can be many times higher than the freight. We collect the current measures against goods from China, with CN codes and rates, in the register of anti-dumping duties.
Checklist for comparing freight forwarder quotes
- Send all freight forwarders the same enquiry template on the same day: route, container, goods with CN code, date and delivery terms.
- Copy each quote into the same columns: freight, surcharges, THC, clearance, documents, delivery.
- For each missing item, ask whether it is included elsewhere, and until you get an answer add a typical amount.
- Convert items in zloty and euro into dollars at one rate from one day.
- Compare totals to port, and assess delivery separately, because it depends on the city.
- Write down the quote validity, the free time from storage charges, insurance and payment terms.
- Check the best quote against the minimum and median from the board.
Frequently asked questions
Is the cheapest quote by total the cheapest quote?
Not always. In the example from 22 September, the quote with the lowest total to port did not include documents, and another low quote included neither clearance nor documents. After filling in the gaps with typical amounts from the board, the order of the quotes changed, so compare only quotes with a complete set of items.
What is BAF and is it always included in the freight price?
BAF is the shipping line's bunker surcharge. It is sometimes included in the freight, in which case the quote is marked "all in", or given separately and changed monthly or quarterly along with the price of marine fuel. Always ask whether the freight includes it before comparing the quote with another.
How many quotes are worth collecting?
Three to five for the same route and the same date are usually enough to see the spread of prices. More quotes rarely add new information and make the comparison harder. In addition, compare the best one with the quotes on the board to check whether the whole set is out of line with the market.
Should you compare quotes to door or to port?
To port, if you want to assess the freight forwarder itself, because the cost of delivery depends on the city, not on who quotes the freight. To door, if you are deciding on the whole cost of delivery and different freight forwarders offer different delivery, or only some of them include it at all.
Sources
- ImportPanel forwarder offers board: three 40HC quotes from Ningbo of 22 September 2026, without freight forwarder names, and typical amounts for clearance and documents in active quotes as of 27 September 2026
- NBP mid rate from table A, reading of 25 September 2026
- Drewry World Container Index: readings in the ImportPanel database of 26 February and 9 July 2026
